Indians want their side
told during Lewis and Clark bicentennial
By ANGIE WAGNER, Associated Press
© May 4, 2003
ON THE LEWIS AND CLARK TRAIL, Mont. -- On
a warm, summer day, his grandfather's blue pickup truck rumbled
down a windy, barren trail, leading the 13-year-old to the old
cottonwood tree by the river.
The boy closed his eyes, raised one arm to
the skies, then gazed at the sun as he sprinkled his traditional
offering of tobacco on the ground -- to the east, to the south,
to the west, to the north.
``You can feel it when you get there,''
William TalksAbout says. ``A sense of calm, security, a sense of
my heritage and my culture being played out even in my mind.''
He's 54 now, but remembers the moment as
if it were yesterday.
Here in the place TalksAbout finds sacred,
two Blackfeet Indians were killed by Meriwether Lewis and one of
his soldiers during the Lewis and Clark expedition in 1806. It
was the only blood shed during the expedition.
But finding out what led to the skirmish
at Two Medicine River depends on who you ask. The Blackfeet say
the story America has been told is false.
As the country celebrates the bicentennial
of the journey by Lewis and William Clark through the newly
acquired Louisiana Purchase and to the Pacific, American Indians
-- so crucial to the expedition's success -- are trying to find
where they fit into the story. They also want to make sure their
side of the story isn't lost in the revelry.
------
On the Fort Peck Indian Reservation in far
northeastern Montana, a sign on the outskirts of Wolf Point
invites tourists to stay: ``Lewis and Clark slept here. Why
don't you?''
The sign is about the only mention of the
expedition in the community of 2,700.
Inside the Wolf Point Cafe downtown,
waitress Janielle Derden, 19, is behind the counter.
``I don't think too many people really
think about it,'' she said. It's a familiar response among
Indians in Montana.
Lewis and Clark? Never paid much
attention, some say. All the history Indians have of Lewis and
Clark, aside from that pressed on them by whites, are the
stories passed down orally from generation to generation.
But with the bicentennial attracting so
much attention, Indians from many tribes are being forced to
confront their feelings about these two white men who passed
through their homelands 200 years ago. Lewis and Clark
documented plants, animals and people while searching
unsuccessfully for an all-water route to the Pacific. Along the
way, they relied on Indians for horses, food and guidance.
Lewis and Clark presented them with gifts
and peace medals from their new ``father,'' President Thomas
Jefferson. And they had a plan for the tribes: Trade exclusively
with Americans and cease fighting with other tribes. The Indians
weren't sure what to make of the men, and didn't know if they
would see their kind again.
That may have been the start of a cultural
difference that still exists today.
``Lewis and Clark kind of had a complex
agenda with Indians,'' said Clay Jenkinson, scholar in residence
at Lewis & Clark College in Portland, Ore. ``It was sort of
pushy. They carried a considerable naivete and a fair amount of
cultural arrogance. It's really a cultural misunderstanding.''
America celebrates Lewis and Clark as
heroes who documented the unknown and opened the West to
expansion. Indians strongly oppose the word ``celebration'' for
the bicentennial; they prefer commemoration for an event that
was just a blip in their history.
``Lewis and Clark was only one day in our
lives,'' said Darrell Martin, vice president of the Fort Belknap
Indian Community Council in north-central Montana. ``We couldn't
care less.''
------
Jim Wilke tosses his head back, his long,
black locks stretching down his back, and has a good laugh.
``The majority of people look at Lewis and
Clark and say, 'What brave souls,''' said Wilke, tourism
director for the Fort Belknap Indian Reservation, home to the
Gros Ventre and Assiniboine Indians. ``I don't quite follow
that.''
When the expedition passed through Indian
territory, there were massive herds of buffalo, elk, deer and
antelope. Since 1974, Fort Belknap has been rebuilding its
buffalo herd, and Wilke, showing visitors around, points out
several hundred buffalo gathered in the bright snow against
Snake Butte.
There were no reservations 200 years ago,
and the problems here today -- methamphetamine labs, alcohol
abuse, diabetes and poverty -- were unknown.
In Lodgepole, a small Roman Catholic
church on a hill is the social hub this Sunday, with
parishioners of St. Thomas Church munching doughnuts and sipping
coffee in the fellowship hall after services.
Lewis and Clark are rarely talked about.
Tracy King, 48, a Gros Ventre Indian,
says, ``If it wasn't Lewis and Clark, it would have been
somebody else.''
But it was Lewis and Clark, and their
impact was huge -- it was the first diplomatic and cultural
contact between many tribes and the United States. Settlers
moved West, opened up trade routes and the American empire began
in the West.
``It was the beginning of contacts that
changed everybody's lives,'' said University of Tulsa historian
James Ronda, a Lewis and Clark expert. ``This is a story that
connects the past to the present. It's a story that is not over
by any means. The real significance of the bicentennial is to
look at where we all are now.''
``This is a story about land, the places
we call home,'' said Bobbie Conner, a member of the Confederated
Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation and director of
Tamastslikt Cultural Institute in Pendleton, Ore. ``It's a tiny,
tiny story but has tremendous impact.''
Some Indians believe the expedition was
the beginning of hard times for tribes. Soon, migration brought
diseases, alcohol and massive slaughter of the buffalo. The
government eventually forced tribes onto reservations that were
a fraction of their native lands.
``Not a single tribe escaped some kind of
relocation or confinement or some kind of misery dealt at the
hands of the federal government,'' said Ben Sherman, an Oglala
Lakota Indian and president of the Denver-based Western American
Indian Chamber.
------
In northwestern Montana, the community of
Browning wakes up to a spring snowfall that has blanketed the
Blackfeet Indian Reservation, nestled against the Rocky Mountain
Front. At the Piegan Institute, students slowly file in to the
private school and load up their breakfast plates with syrupy
waffles.
Here in a reservation plagued by poverty,
the school is one of the few bright spots, offering hope and a
chance to reconnect students to their past by learning their
native language. The chalkboards and walls are full of words
that are foreign to anyone but the Blackfeet. The 30 students
speak only Blackfeet in school; English is for after school.
They all know the story of what happened
to two Blackfeet boys during the expedition. But their version
is different from that told in the expedition journals.
Jesse DesRosier, a 14-year-old with long
brown hair braided down his back, tells the story like this: Two
Blackfeet boys -- 12 and 13 -- were on their way home when the
men of the expedition spotted them and invited them to camp.
``Lewis kept insisting they camp with
them. He said, we have a gift for you, and they had hands on
guns at all times,'' he said.
In the middle of the night, the boys tried
to leave. One of Lewis' men woke up and stabbed one boy. Lewis
shot the other.
Lewis contended the Indians were trying to
steal the men's guns. Reuben Fields killed one Blackfeet, and
when Indians tried to steal horses, Lewis shot the other. They
didn't say how old they thought they were.
``It made the Blackfeet not trust the
white people'' long afterward, Jesse said.
By late morning, the students are
practicing a Lewis and Clark play they will perform at the
Confluence of Cultures, a Lewis and Clark event this spring at
the University of Montana in Missoula. They act out the deadly
encounter with Lewis and Clark, with Jesse playing one of the
slain boys.
Then the play shifts into what happened to
Indians in the years following the expedition. Students are
brought to a boarding school and told not to speak their native
language, a reference to when the government forced Indians into
mission schools and tried to strip them of everything Indian.
``I think Lewis and Clark were bad guys,''
said John Leo Bird, 8.
At Fort Belknap, Indians are preparing a
skit for tourists that depicts Lewis and Clark getting lost
repeatedly and relying on the Indians for guidance.
``We like to say we're the ones who
discovered Lewis and Clark,'' said Robert DesRosier, 51, a
Blackfeet Indian and Jesse's uncle.
------
With three years of bicentennial events,
starting this year, Indian tribes know tourists are bound to
show up in their communities. And while they know they won't
agree with many visitors about Lewis and Clark, they don't want
their role limited to dancing at a commemorative event.
They figure they might as well try to make
a little money. Many are working on arts and crafts, reservation
tours and story telling.
``If there's some money to be made off
this thing, let's join in and attract some tourists ourselves,''
Sherman said.
What Indians really hope happens during
the bicentennial is a better understanding of their culture. And
they want to tell their story, their side of the expedition.
``For so long, people thought that you
just had these two American guys who came out and explored the
West,'' said Amy Mossett, a Mandan and Hidatsa Indian and
tourism director for the Mandan, Hidatsa and Arikara Tribes in
North Dakota. ``For us Native Americans, nothing could be
further from the truth.
``We don't want a lot of these
Lewis-and-Clark hero-worshippers and 'Thomas Jefferson was the
greatest.' We had visions, too. We had civilization.''
But Darrell Kipp, a Harvard-educated
Blackfeet who co-founded the Piegan Institute, said tourists
don't want to hear about how Indians lost their land and were
devastated by disease. They want the hero story.
``As much as American Indians don't think
much about Lewis and Clark, a lot of Americans don't think about
Indians,'' he said.
``Lewis and Clark marks a long
misunderstanding of Native Americans. I think Lewis and Clark
didn't understand who Native Americans were,'' Kipp said. ``They
weren't there long enough to really find out what these people
are about.''
They are, Kipp said, invisible Americans.
Tribes are hoping the bicentennial changes that.
They want America to know they were here
before Lewis and Clark.
And here they remain.
© 2003 HamptonRoads.com/PilotOnline.com
|